documentMany years after New York Times v. SullivanHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
I myself was charged with defamation—indeed criminal defamation—for exercising my own freedom of speech to criticize a judge for an opinion she wrote. This certainly made me appreciate our First Amendment. Here is the story:
document“The theory of our Constitution is that every citizen may speak his mind and every newspaper express its view on matters of public concernHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
and may not be barred from speaking or publishing because those in control of government think that what is said or written is unwise
documentIn addition to the defamatory statement being directed against a specific individualHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
it must also cast him in a negative light. That used to be easier to define than it is today. For example
documentWhenever a Holocaust denier or defamer of the Jews spews out his poisonHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
I get calls and emails demanding that I sue them for defaming the Jewish people or committing a “blood libel.” But under our First Amendment only an individual can be defamed. There is no such thing as group libel. In other words you can sa...
documentAcademic freedom is not limited to faculty. It extends to students as wellHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
and no professor has the right to propagandize his captive classroom audience or to grade them down if they disagree with his political opinions. But it is sometimes difficult to distinguish between acceptable teaching and unacceptable pros...
documentLike the character in the “Groves of AcademeHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
” Mr. Finkelstein generated protests by students and outsiders. He has encouraged radical goons to email threatening messages; “Look forward to a visit from me
documentThe final part of Mr. Finkelstein’s quest for tenure is to blame his tenure problems on “outsiders.” He claims that I intruded myself into the DePaul review processHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
neglecting to mention that I was specifically asked by the former chairman of DePaul’s political science department to “point [him] to the clearest and most egregious instances of dishonesty on Finkelstein’s part.” I responded by providing....
documentAnother example of the confusion between defending someone’s right to speak and reporting that person’s views on the merits of his speech arose in the context of efforts by Norman FinkelsteinHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
a failed academic who had been fired from several universities
documentBut academic freedom is not the province of the hard left alone. Academic freedom includes the right to agree with the governmentHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
to defend the government and to work for the government. Some of the same hard leftists who demand academic freedom for themselves and their ideological colleagues were among the leaders of those seeking to deny academic freedom to a distin...
documentIsraeli academics are free to challenge not only the legitimacy of the Jewish state but evenHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
documentNot everyone understands this distinction. My own mother insisted that I was “helping” Nazis and terrorists when I supported their right to speakHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
even while condemning what they were saying. Far better educated people than my mother also claimed not to understand. In a debate in Canada on laws criminalizing Holocaust denial
documentThe orchestra board responded that Redgrave has earned more money since the cancellation than before itHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
documentRedgrave herself has used her art “to do the work” of terrorists. In 1977House Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
she made a film calling for the destruction of the Jewish state by armed struggle. She has personally received training in terrorism at camps from which terrorist raids were staged. She advocated the assassination of Nobel Peace Prize winne...
documentAD: And I have faith in the American people that they will reject your ideas in the marketplace of ideas and you should not have the benefit of censorship so that you can stand up and proclaim your views. You knowHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
documentAD: The only publicity you will get from me is the most negative kind of publicity because I sayHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
your ideas belong in a nutshell because they are nutty ideas
documentAD: My purposes are the purposes of the First Amendment. Mr. HaleHouse Oversight Committee — Epstein Estate Records (Nov 2025)1 pp.
you will rue the day that you ever thought that I would give you publicity because I will not stop condemning your organization and you know that the only condition that I will accept your case is because you have given me the freedom to ar...